The Politics of Tariffs

 

Is Raghuram Rajan wrong about his economic forecasts for India?

 

Understanding India's Development Challenges: Raghuram Rajan

 

Atif Mian on the Economic Reality of Pakistan

 

A level Economics: How Chicago school economists reshaped American justice

From The Economist

In recent years the antitrust division of America’s Department of Justice has gone on a crusade against corporate mergers, filing a record number of complaints in an attempt to stop the biggest businesses from getting even bigger. With few exceptions, these efforts have been thwarted by the courts. That it is so hard to get a judge to intervene in business reflects the work of an institution known more for its free-market influence on economics than the law: the University of Chicago.

Fifty years ago this autumn Richard Posner, a federal judge and Chicago scholar, published his “Economic Analysis of Law”. Now in its 9th edition, the book set off an avalanche of ideas from Chicago school economists, including Gary Becker, Ronald Coase and Milton Friedman, which passed into the folios of America’s judges and lawyers. The “law-and-economics” movement made the courts more reasoned and rigorous. It also changed the verdicts judges handed out. Research has found that those exposed to its ideas are more opposed to regulators and less likely to enforce antitrust laws, and tend to impose prison terms more often and for longer.

Links between economics and the law have long been studied. In “Leviathan”, published in 1651, Thomas Hobbes wrote that secure property rights, which are needed for a system of economic exchange, are a legal fiction that emerged only with the modern state. By the late 19th century, legal fields that overlapped with economics, such as matters of taxation, were being analysed by economists.

With the arrival of the law-and-economics movement, every legal question was suddenly addressed in the context of the incentives of actors and the changes these produced. In “Crime and punishment: an economic approach” (1968), Becker argued that, rather than being a balancing-act between punishment and the opportunity for reform, sentences act mainly as a deterrent: the literal “price of crime”. Harsh sentences, he argued, reduce criminal activity in much the same way as high prices cut demand. With the caveat that a greater chance of arrest is a better deterrent than longer prison sentences, Becker’s theorising has since been borne out by decades of empirical evidence.

Too steep?

In the movement’s early days, “the legal academy paid little attention to our work”, recalls Guido Calabresi, a former dean of Yale Law School and another of the field’s founding fathers. Two things changed this. The first was Mr Posner’s bestselling textbook, in which he wrote that “it may be possible to deduce the basic formal characteristics of law itself from economic theory.” Mr Posner was a jurist, who wrote in a language familiar to other jurists. Yet he was also steeped in the economic insights of the Chicago school. His book successfully thrust the law-and-economics movement into the legal mainstream.

The second factor was a two-week programme called the Manne Economics Institute for Federal Judges, which ran from 1976 until 1998. This was funded by businesses and conservative foundations, and involved an all-expenses-paid stay at a beachside hotel in Miami. It was no holiday, however, even if those who went nicknamed the conference “Pareto in the Palms”. The curriculum was extremely demanding, taught by economists including Friedman and Paul Samuelson, both of whom had won Nobel prizes.

image: the economist

By the early 1990s nearly half the federal judiciary had spent a few weeks in Miami. Those who attended included two future justices on the Supreme Court: Clarence Thomas (an arch conservative) and Ruth Bader Ginsburg (his liberal counterpart). Ginsburg would later surprise colleagues by voting with the conservative majority on antitrust cases, applying the so-called “consumer welfare standard” championed by the Manne programme. This states that a corporate merger is anticompetitive only if it raises the price or reduces the quality of goods or services. Ginsburg wrote that the instruction she received in Miami “was far more intense than the Florida sun”.

In a paper under review by the Quarterly Journal of Economics, Elliot Ash of eth Zurich, Daniel Chen of Princeton University and Suresh Naidu of Columbia University treat the Manne programme as a natural experiment, comparing the decisions of every alumnus before and after their attendance at the conference. They then use an artificial-intelligence approach called “word embedding” to assess the language in judges’ opinions in more than a million circuit- and district- court cases.

The researchers find that federal judges were more likely to use terms such as “efficiency” and “market”, and less likely to use those such as “discharged” and “revoke”, after time spent in Miami. Manne alumni took what the authors characterised as the “conservative” stance on antitrust and other economic cases 30% more often in the years after attending. They also imposed prison sentences 5% more frequently and of 25% greater length. The effect became stronger still after 2005, when a Supreme Court decision gave federal judges greater discretion over sentencing.

That researchers are turning the unforgiving lens of economic analysis on law and economics itself is a promising trend. The dismal science has come a long way since the heyday of the Chicago school. Thanks in large part to the empiricism of behavioural economics, it is less wedded to abstractions like the perfectly rational actor. This has softened some of the Chicago school’s harsher edges. But it will nevertheless take time for judges to modify their approach. As Mr Ash notes: “The Chicago school economists may all be retired or dead, but Manne alumni continue to be active members of the judiciary.” In courtrooms across America, Mr Posner’s influence will live on for decades to come.

Skills Wars Are The New Trade Wars | Economics Explained

 

A Level Economics: Practice Questions on Globalisation

MCQs 

1. Globalisation refers to the increasing interconnectedness and interdependence of economies, cultures, and societies around the world, driven by advancements in technology, transportation, and communication. What key factors have facilitated the movement of goods, services, capital, information, and people across borders?

a) Government intervention and protectionist measures b) Technological advancements, transportation, and communication c) Trade barriers and tariffs d) Currency exchange controls

Solution: b) Technological advancements, transportation, and communication

2. How does globalisation differ from free trade?

a) Globalisation promotes government intervention in trade, while free trade advocates for the removal of trade barriers. b) Globalisation involves only the exchange of goods and services, while free trade encompasses movements of capital, labor, technology, and ideas as well. c) Globalisation aims to create cultural exchange between countries, while free trade focuses solely on economic integration. d) Globalisation is a specific policy approach, while free trade is a broader concept of international integration.

Solution: b) Globalisation involves not only the exchange of goods and services but also movements of capital, labor, technology, and ideas across borders.

3. What are some of the benefits of globalisation?

a) Increased income inequality and job displacement b) Environmental degradation and financial instability c) Access to larger markets, technology and innovation, and cultural exchange d) Dependency on global markets and cultural homogenisation

Solution: c) Access to larger markets, technology and innovation, and cultural exchange

4. Which of the following is NOT a challenge associated with globalisation?

a) Environmental impact and unsustainable resource consumption b) Growing income inequality within countries c) Limited fiscal coordination among member states d) Financial instability due to interconnected global financial markets

Solution: c) Limited fiscal coordination among member states (This is a challenge related to the Eurozone, not specifically to globalisation)

5. The World Trade Organization (WTO) plays a crucial role in policing trade agreements between nations. What is the primary function of the WTO's dispute settlement system?

a) To remove barriers and restrictions on the flow of goods and services b) To monitor and supervise global trade policies and developments c) To facilitate negotiations with countries seeking to join the WTO d) To adjudicate and resolve disputes when member countries violate WTO trade rules

Solution: d) To adjudicate and resolve disputes when member countries violate WTO trade rules

6. What is the role of the WTO's Trade Policy Reviews (TPRs)?

a) To conduct regular reviews of the WTO's performance and effectiveness b) To examine the trade policies and practices of each member country and provide feedback and recommendations c) To promote cultural exchange and appreciation of diversity among nations d) To streamline customs procedures and reduce trade costs for businesses

Solution: b) To examine the trade policies and practices of each member country and provide feedback and recommendations

7. Which of the following is a benefit of an increasingly integrated world economy for the UK?

a) Competition and job displacement b) Access to larger markets and foreign investment c) Currency volatility and environmental concerns d) Political instability and lack of basic services

Solution: b) Access to larger markets and foreign investment

8. What economic challenges are commonly faced by Less Economically Developed Countries (LEDCs)?

a) Income inequality and aging population b) Unemployment and currency volatility c) Poverty and lack of basic services d) Environmental concerns and technological advancements

Solution: c) Poverty and lack of basic services

9. Which example represents a Major Export Sector in the UK?

a) Agriculture and textiles b) Technology and software c) Financial services and insurance d) Heavy machinery and construction equipment

Solution: c) Financial services and insurance

10. What are the economic problems associated with aging population in More Economically Developed Countries (MEDCs)?

a) Unemployment and underemployment b) Income inequality and environmental impact c) Insufficient infrastructure and political instability d) Increased demand for healthcare and pension systems

Solution: d) Increased demand for healthcare and pension systems

---

Long Answer Questions

1. What are the key drivers of globalisation, and how have they facilitated the movement of goods, services, capital, information, and people across borders?

2. 
   

3. Compare and contrast globalisation with free trade, highlighting their respective roles in promoting international integration and economic exchange.

4. 
   

5. Analyse the benefits and challenges of globalisation, considering its impact on trade, economic growth, cultural exchange, and income inequality among countries.

6. 
   

7. Evaluate the role of the World Trade Organization (WTO) in policing trade agreements, resolving disputes, and facilitating trade negotiations among member countries.

8. 
   

9. Assess the economic problems faced by More Economically Developed Countries (MEDCs), Less Economically Developed Countries (LEDCs), and Emerging Economies, and propose potential policy measures to address these challenges for each category of countries.

A Level Economics 97: Globalisation

Globalisation refers to the increasing interconnectedness and interdependence of economies, cultures, and societies around the world. It is driven by advancements in technology, transportation, and communication, which have facilitated the movement of goods, services, capital, information, and people across borders. Globalisation has led to a significant increase in international trade, investment, and cultural exchange, resulting in a more integrated and interconnected global community.

Distinguishing Globalisation and Free Trade: Globalisation is a broader concept that encompasses various aspects of international integration, including not only trade in goods and services but also movements of capital, labour, technology, and ideas across borders. It involves a complex network of economic, social, cultural, and political connections between countries.

On the other hand, free trade is a specific policy approach that aims to remove barriers and restrictions on the flow of goods and services between countries. It promotes the idea of allowing markets to function without government intervention, tariffs, quotas, or other protectionist measures that hinder the exchange of goods and services.

Benefits of Globalisation:

1. Increased Trade and Economic Growth: Globalisation has facilitated trade and investment, leading to economic growth and higher living standards in many countries.
2. 
   
3. Access to New Markets: Globalisation provides businesses with access to larger international markets, enabling them to reach a wider customer base.
4. 
   
5. Technology and Innovation: Globalisation fosters the spread of technology and innovation, driving productivity improvements and technological advancements worldwide.
6. 
   
7. Cultural Exchange: Greater interconnectedness has allowed for cultural exchange and appreciation of diversity among nations.
8. 
   
9. Foreign Direct Investment (FDI): Globalisation attracts foreign investment, which can lead to the development of industries and infrastructure in host countries.

Costs of Globalisation:

1. Income Inequality: Globalisation has been associated with growing income inequality within countries, where certain segments of society benefit more than others.
2. 
   
3. Job Displacement: The relocation of industries to countries with lower production costs can result in job losses in some regions, leading to structural unemployment.
4. 
   
5. Environmental Impact: Increased global economic activities have raised concerns about environmental degradation and unsustainable resource consumption.
6. 
   
7. Dependency on Global Markets: Developing countries may become overly dependent on international markets, making them vulnerable to external economic shocks.
8. 
   
9. Financial Instability: Interconnected global financial markets can lead to financial crises, as demonstrated in the 2008 global financial crisis.
10. 
    
11. Cultural Homogenisation: Some argue that globalisation may lead to the erosion of unique cultural identities as more dominant cultures influence others.

Evaluating the Costs and Benefits: The costs and benefits of globalisation are not distributed equally among all countries and individuals. Developed economies with advanced industries tend to benefit more from globalisation due to their competitive advantages. Meanwhile, developing countries may face challenges and vulnerabilities, particularly in terms of income inequality and the risk of deindustrialisation.

Policymakers need to address the downsides of globalisation by implementing measures that mitigate negative impacts and ensure that the benefits are more inclusive. This can include investing in education and skills development, social safety nets, and sustainable environmental practices.

Overall, the evaluation of globalisation's costs and benefits is context-dependent and requires a nuanced understanding of the specific challenges and opportunities faced by different countries and societies. Balancing global integration with domestic development goals is essential for harnessing the potential benefits of globalisation while mitigating its negative consequences.

---

Major Export Sectors in the UK: The UK has a diverse range of export sectors, but some of the major ones include:

1. Financial Services: The UK is a global financial hub, with London being a prominent center for financial services, including banking, insurance, and asset management.

2. 
   

3. Manufacturing: The UK exports various manufactured goods, including automobiles, aerospace products, pharmaceuticals, and machinery.

4. 
   

5. Oil and Gas: The UK is a significant exporter of oil and gas products, benefiting from its North Sea oil reserves.

6. 
   

7. Professional Services: The UK exports professional services such as legal, accounting, and consulting services to countries around the world.

8. 
   

9. Creative Industries: The UK is a major exporter of creative goods and services, including films, music, video games, and television programs.

10. 
    

11. Pharmaceuticals and Life Sciences: The UK exports pharmaceutical products and medical equipment, driven by its strong research and development capabilities.

Evaluation of the Benefits of an Increasingly Integrated World Economy to the UK: An increasingly integrated world economy, characterized by globalisation, has both benefits and challenges for the UK:

Benefits:

1. Access to Larger Markets: Integration allows UK businesses to access larger international markets, expanding their customer base and revenue potential.

2. 
   

3. Economies of Scale: Increased trade and cross-border investment can lead to economies of scale, reducing production costs and increasing efficiency.

4. 
   

5. Enhanced Innovation: Integration fosters knowledge-sharing and innovation as the UK can access cutting-edge technology and ideas from other countries.

6. 
   

7. Foreign Investment: An integrated world economy attracts foreign direct investment, which brings in capital, technology, and expertise to the UK.

8. 
   

9. Diversification of Exports: The UK can reduce reliance on domestic markets by diversifying its exports to multiple countries, reducing vulnerability to domestic economic fluctuations.

10. 
    

11. Cultural Exchange: Globalisation promotes cultural exchange, leading to a richer, more diverse cultural landscape in the UK.

Challenges:

1. Competition: Increased integration exposes UK industries to heightened global competition, which may negatively impact certain sectors.

2. 
   

3. Income Inequality: Globalisation can exacerbate income inequality, as some segments of society may benefit more than others.

4. 
   

5. Job Displacement: Some UK workers may face job displacement due to international competition and outsourcing.

6. 
   

7. Environmental Impact: Globalisation can lead to increased environmental pressures as trade and transportation volumes grow.

8. 
   

9. Financial Instability: Integration can result in financial contagion, as demonstrated in the 2008 global financial crisis.

Overall Evaluation: An increasingly integrated world economy has been beneficial to the UK in many ways, particularly by opening up new markets, attracting investment, and fostering innovation. The UK's status as a global financial and business hub has been strengthened by its participation in the global economy.

However, challenges such as income inequality, job displacement, and environmental concerns need to be addressed through appropriate policies. By focusing on inclusive growth, investing in education and skills development, and implementing sustainable practices, the UK can reap the benefits of an integrated world economy while mitigating its negative effects. A balanced approach that considers the welfare of all citizens and promotes sustainable development is essential for maximizing the benefits of globalisation in the UK.

---

The World Trade Organization (WTO) is an international organization that deals with the global rules of trade between nations. It was established on January 1, 1995, and succeeded the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT). The WTO operates as a forum for member countries to negotiate and set trade rules, resolve disputes, and ensure the smooth functioning of international trade.

Role in Policing Trade Agreements: The WTO plays a crucial role in policing trade agreements through various mechanisms:

1. Dispute Settlement Mechanism: One of the primary functions of the WTO is its dispute settlement system. When member countries believe that another member is violating WTO trade rules, they can bring a dispute to the WTO's Dispute Settlement Body (DSB). The DSB hears and adjudicates disputes, ensuring that countries comply with their trade commitments and do not resort to unilateral protectionist measures.

2. 
   

3. Trade Policy Reviews: The WTO conducts regular Trade Policy Reviews (TPRs) of member countries. During these reviews, the trade policies and practices of each member are examined, promoting transparency and providing an opportunity for constructive feedback and recommendations.

4. 
   

5. Monitoring and Surveillance: The WTO continuously monitors global trade policies and developments. It helps identify potential trade barriers and encourages members to abide by agreed-upon rules, thereby fostering a fair and predictable trading environment.

6. 
   

7. Notification Requirements: Member countries are required to notify the WTO about their trade-related measures, such as tariffs, subsidies, and technical regulations. This promotes transparency and ensures that other countries are informed about potential impacts on their trade interests.

Role in Trade Negotiations: The WTO also plays a significant role in trade negotiations:

1. Multilateral Trade Negotiations: The WTO hosts multilateral negotiations among member countries to address various trade issues, such as reducing tariffs, eliminating trade barriers, and liberalizing trade in specific sectors. These negotiations aim to achieve mutually beneficial outcomes for all participating countries.

2. 
   

3. Accession Negotiations: The WTO facilitates negotiations with countries seeking to join the organization. Prospective members must negotiate and make specific commitments to adhere to WTO rules and regulations.

4. 
   

5. Trade Facilitation Agreement: The WTO reached a landmark Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA) in 2013, which aims to streamline and simplify customs procedures to expedite trade and reduce trade costs for businesses.

Overall, the WTO acts as a neutral platform for member countries to engage in trade negotiations, resolve disputes, and ensure compliance with trade agreements. By providing a rules-based framework for international trade, the WTO contributes to the stability and predictability of the global trading system, promoting economic growth and development worldwide. However, like any international organization, the WTO faces challenges in reconciling the diverse interests of its member countries and addressing complex and evolving trade issues in a rapidly changing global economic landscape.

---

1. More Economically Developed Countries (MEDCs): Refers to countries with advanced industrialization, high levels of economic development, and relatively high standards of living.

2. 
   

3. Less Economically Developed Countries (LEDCs): Refers to countries with lower levels of industrialization, lower income levels, and often facing socio-economic challenges.

4. 
   

5. Emerging Economies: Refers to countries that are transitioning from low-income to middle-income status and experiencing rapid economic growth and development.

Economic Problems Facing MEDCs:

1. Unemployment and Underemployment: Even in advanced economies, cyclical or structural unemployment can be a persistent issue. Technological advancements and changes in industries can lead to job displacement, creating challenges in providing employment opportunities.

2. 
   

3. Income Inequality: MEDCs may experience significant income disparities between the rich and the poor. This can result from factors such as differences in education, skills, and access to resources.

4. 
   

5. Aging Population: Many MEDCs face the challenge of an aging population, leading to increased demand for healthcare and pension systems, which can strain public finances.

6. 
   

7. Environmental Concerns: Developed countries often face environmental problems due to high consumption levels and industrial activities, such as pollution, climate change, and resource depletion.

Economic Problems Facing LEDCs:

1. Poverty and Lack of Basic Services: LEDCs often struggle with widespread poverty and inadequate access to essential services such as education, healthcare, and clean water.

2. 
   

3. Infrastructure Deficiencies: Many LEDCs have limited infrastructure, hindering economic development and trade. Insufficient transportation, energy, and communication networks can hamper economic growth.

4. 
   

5. Debt Burden: LEDCs may accumulate substantial external debts, making it challenging to finance development projects and service debt obligations.

6. 
   

7. Political Instability: Political instability and governance issues can hinder investment and economic growth in LEDCs.

Economic Problems Facing Emerging Economies:

1. Income Disparities: Rapid economic growth in emerging economies can lead to income inequalities and disparities between urban and rural areas.

2. 
   

3. Currency Volatility: Emerging economies may face currency volatility due to external shocks or speculative activities, impacting their trade and overall economic stability.

4. 
   

5. Infrastructure Development: Despite growth, many emerging economies require significant investment in infrastructure to sustain their development trajectory.

6. 
   

7. Corruption and Governance Challenges: Weak governance and corruption can hinder economic progress and deter foreign investment.

Examples:

1. MEDC Example: The United States faces challenges in reducing income inequality, providing affordable healthcare, and transitioning to a greener economy to address environmental concerns.

2. LEDC Example: Sub-Saharan African countries often confront poverty, lack of access to education and healthcare, and inadequate infrastructure, impeding their economic development.

3. Emerging Economy Example: India's rapid economic growth has led to income disparities between urban and rural areas, and the country must invest in infrastructure to maintain its growth momentum.

Each category of countries faces unique economic challenges that require tailored policies and strategies for sustainable development and inclusive growth. Governments and policymakers need to address these issues proactively to ensure socio-economic progress and stability.