China’s recent economic woes suggest there is something seriously amiss

George Magnus in The Guardian

At a Politburo meeting last month, China’s leaders referred to the economic recovery this year as “torturous”. You won’t often hear such candour coming from a Chinese Communist party institution, let alone such an elevated body. They were referring to current conditions, of course, but China’s problems reveal much that is systemically out of kilter in its economic and political system.

During the past few days, some of the statistics China has published have caused a stir. Consumer prices in July were lower than a year ago, suggesting it might be on the cusp of deflation, which reflects a chronic shortage of demand in the economy. And China’s foreign trade in the same month showed a sharp fall in exports due to weak global demand, with a sharper decline in imports signifying weakness in demand at home. There were murky factors affecting both but the message is that something more serious is amiss in China.


Indeed, China was widely expected to bounce back from the pandemic and there was a bit of a flurry early in 2023. Yet, consumption has generally been very subdued especially for big-ticket items such as cars and houses, and private investment, the backbone of China’s economy, fell in the first half of this year, for the first time since such data was published many years ago.

Private firms and entrepreneurs are not spending much on investment or on hiring people. Youth unemployment has topped 21%, or double what it is in the UK and almost three times the rate in the US. The annual graduation of 11-12 million students in the the summer is aggravating an already difficult situation because of the problems of finding suitable work, and also because the Chinese labour market has become one in which most jobs are in the lower-pay, low-skill, gig or informal economy compared with higher quality jobs in manufacturing and construction.

It would be wrong though to pin this all on the pandemic. Most things weighing on China’s economy have been building for several years, even while much of the world was wowed by China’s global brands such as Huawei, Alibaba, Tencent and TikTok, property was booming, and China was leaving its footprint all over the world through the “belt and road” initiative and its rising governance engagement with global entities such as the International Monetary Fund and the World Health Organization.

In spite of its unequivocal accomplishments and successes, China has, during the past decade or more, spawned a mountain of bad debt, unprofitable and uncommercial infrastructure and real estate, empty apartment blocks and little-used apartments and transport facilities, and excess capacity in, for example, coal, steel, solar panels and electric vehicles. Productivity growth has stalled, and China can unfortunately boast one of the world’s highest levels of inequality.

It is ageing faster than any other country on the planet but with a skinny social security system in which most of its 290 million migrant workers are not eligible for most social benefits. Under Xi Jinping, moreover, it has also developed an increasingly repressive, state-centric and controlling governance system, both for political reasons and to deal with the effects of its failing development model.

These are testing times for Chinese citizens, especially the fabled rising middle class whose savings have mostly found a home in an outsized real estate sector which has now entered a period of structural decline. Most of the housing stock, overbuilding, collapse in transactions and weakness in prices are not in big agglomerations such as Beijing, Shenzhen and Shanghai, but in hundreds of smaller cities and towns that rarely make news.

China’s leaders have been vocal this year about strengthening consumption and about improving the business environment for private firms and entrepreneurs, who have been pressured or punished to align their commercial interest with the party’s political goals. We still await evidence that such rhetoric has substance.

In the coming weeks and months, we should probably expect the authorities to ease financial and budgetary policies, housing regulations, and borrowing caps to finance infrastructure. There might even be measures that look consumer-friendly but also fail to boost the income that alone can sustain higher consumption.

These things may give the economy a temporary lift over the winter but the underlying weakness of the economy and the greater authoritarianism that China features are now two sides of the same coin that seem irreversible, certainly for the time being.

It is a moot point whether this sort of China in the 2020s is a bigger threat to geopolitical stability than one in which it confidently strides the world stage and is able to brush aside liberal leaning democracies and reframe global governance in its interests. But a crucial one to get right.

A Level Economics: Practice Questions on Exchange Rates

In a fixed exchange rate system, the central bank or government intervenes in the foreign exchange market to:

1. a) Increase interest rates b) Devalue the domestic currency c) Maintain a constant exchange rate d) Allow the exchange rate to float freely

   Solution: c) Maintain a constant exchange rate

2. 
   

3. The exchange rate in a floating exchange rate system is primarily determined by: a) Central bank interventions b) Market forces of demand and supply c) Government policies d) Trade imbalances

   Solution: b) Market forces of demand and supply

4. 
   

5. In a managed exchange rate system, the central bank occasionally intervenes in the foreign exchange market to: a) Fix the exchange rate b) Allow the exchange rate to float freely c) Influence the exchange rate within a certain range d) Prevent any exchange rate fluctuations

   Solution: c) Influence the exchange rate within a certain range

6. 
   

7. What happens to the value of a currency in a free-float system when the demand for that currency exceeds its supply? a) The value appreciates b) The value depreciates c) The value remains constant d) The value fluctuates randomly

   Solution: a) The value appreciates

8. 
   

9. Which factor does NOT contribute to the demand for a currency? a) Exports b) Capital outflows c) Capital inflows d) Investments

   Solution: b) Capital outflows

10. 
    

11. In a free-float exchange rate system, what happens when a country imports goods and services from other countries? a) The supply of its currency increases b) The supply of its currency decreases c) The value of its currency appreciates d) The value of its currency depreciates

    Solution: a) The supply of its currency increases

12. 
    

13. What factor can cause a country's currency to appreciate in value? a) Higher interest rates b) Large-scale quantitative easing c) Trade deficits d) Global uncertainty

    Solution: a) Higher interest rates

14. 
    

15. Which policy objective may be affected by exchange rate changes in a country with an inflation targeting regime? a) Economic growth b) Trade balance c) Inflation d) Exchange rate stability

    Solution: c) Inflation

16. 
    

17. In a floating exchange rate system, how can a weaker currency impact a country's trade balance? a) Improve the trade balance by making exports cheaper b) Worsen the trade balance by making imports cheaper c) Have no effect on the trade balance d) Decrease the demand for exports

    Solution: a) Improve the trade balance by making exports cheaper

18. 
    

19. How can a currency depreciation impact a firm with foreign debt? a) Reduce the firm's foreign debt burden b) Increase the firm's foreign debt burden c) Have no effect on the firm's foreign debt d) Reduce the firm's export competitiveness

    Solution: b) Increase the firm's foreign debt burden

1. The current exchange rate between the US Dollar (USD) and the Euro (EUR) is 1 USD = 0.85 EUR. If you exchange 500 USD into EUR, how much EUR will you receive? a) 425 EUR b) 500 EUR c) 425 USD d) 589 EUR

Solution: To convert USD to EUR, we multiply the amount in USD by the exchange rate. 500 USD * 0.85 EUR/USD = 425 EUR

Correct answer: a) 425 EUR

2. The exchange rate between the British Pound (GBP) and the Japanese Yen (JPY) is 1 GBP = 150 JPY. If you have 10,000 JPY and want to convert it to GBP, how much GBP will you receive? a) 0.0667 GBP b) 66.67 GBP c) 150 GBP d) 15,000 GBP

Solution: To convert JPY to GBP, we divide the amount in JPY by the exchange rate. 10,000 JPY / 150 JPY/GBP = 66.67 GBP

Correct answer: b) 66.67 GBP

3. The central bank of a country decides to devalue its currency by 10%. If the current exchange rate is 1 USD = 100 units of the domestic currency, what will be the new exchange rate after the devaluation? a) 1 USD = 110 units b) 1 USD = 100 units c) 1 USD = 90 units d) 1 USD = 10 units

Solution: To calculate the new exchange rate after the devaluation, we need to reduce the value of the domestic currency by 10%. New exchange rate = 100 units - (10% of 100 units) = 100 units - 10 units = 90 units

Correct answer: c) 1 USD = 90 units

4. The Euro to Swiss Franc (CHF) exchange rate has increased from 1 EUR = 1.10 CHF to 1 EUR = 1.25 CHF. By what percentage has the Euro appreciated against the Swiss Franc? a) 12.5% b) 13.6% c) 14.8% d) 25%

Solution: To calculate the percentage appreciation, we use the formula: Percentage appreciation = ((New rate - Old rate) / Old rate) * 100 Percentage appreciation = ((1.25 CHF - 1.10 CHF) / 1.10 CHF) * 100 Percentage appreciation = (0.15 CHF / 1.10 CHF) * 100 Percentage appreciation = 13.6%

Correct answer: b) 13.6%

5. A tourist from Country A visits Country B and converts 1,000 units of Country A's currency to Country B's currency at an exchange rate of 1 Country A unit = 0.75 Country B units. The tourist spends all the money and converts the remaining Country B currency back to Country A currency at an exchange rate of 1 Country A unit = 0.80 Country B units. How much Country A currency does the tourist get after converting back the money? a) 750 units b) 800 units c) 933.33 units d) 1,066.67 units

Solution: First, we calculate how much Country B currency the tourist receives in Country B. Amount in Country B currency = 1,000 units (Country A currency) * 0.75 Country B units / 1 Country A unit = 750 units (Country B currency)

Now, the tourist converts the 750 units of Country B currency back to Country A currency using the new exchange rate. Amount in Country A currency = 750 units (Country B currency) * 1 Country A unit / 0.80 Country B units = 937.5 units (Country A currency)

Correct answer: c) 933.33 units (rounded to two decimal places)

---

Long Answer Questions

1. Analyze the advantages and disadvantages of a fixed exchange rate system compared to a floating exchange rate system, considering factors such as monetary policy flexibility, trade balance adjustments, and exchange rate stability.

2. 
   

3. Evaluate the impact of a managed exchange rate system on a country's economy. Discuss the effectiveness of occasional central bank interventions in stabilizing the currency while allowing it to float within a certain range. Consider how this system addresses trade imbalances and speculative trading.

4. 
   

5. Assess the implications of a country's currency depreciation on its domestic economy and international trade. Analyze how a weaker currency affects export-oriented industries, import-dependent sectors, and inflation levels, and discuss possible policy responses to manage these effects.

6. 
   

7. Analyze the role of interest rates in influencing exchange rate fluctuations. Evaluate the relationship between higher interest rates, capital inflows, and currency appreciation, and discuss the potential challenges a country may face when adopting such a policy to attract foreign investment.

8. 
   

9. Evaluate the impact of major global events, such as the COVID-19 pandemic or geopolitical tensions, on exchange rates and currency movements. Analyze how safe-haven demand, quantitative easing measures, and changes in trade flows can affect the exchange rates of specific currencies and their implications on international trade dynamics.

A Level Economics 97: Globalisation

Globalisation refers to the increasing interconnectedness and interdependence of economies, cultures, and societies around the world. It is driven by advancements in technology, transportation, and communication, which have facilitated the movement of goods, services, capital, information, and people across borders. Globalisation has led to a significant increase in international trade, investment, and cultural exchange, resulting in a more integrated and interconnected global community.

Distinguishing Globalisation and Free Trade: Globalisation is a broader concept that encompasses various aspects of international integration, including not only trade in goods and services but also movements of capital, labour, technology, and ideas across borders. It involves a complex network of economic, social, cultural, and political connections between countries.

On the other hand, free trade is a specific policy approach that aims to remove barriers and restrictions on the flow of goods and services between countries. It promotes the idea of allowing markets to function without government intervention, tariffs, quotas, or other protectionist measures that hinder the exchange of goods and services.

Benefits of Globalisation:

1. Increased Trade and Economic Growth: Globalisation has facilitated trade and investment, leading to economic growth and higher living standards in many countries.
2. 
   
3. Access to New Markets: Globalisation provides businesses with access to larger international markets, enabling them to reach a wider customer base.
4. 
   
5. Technology and Innovation: Globalisation fosters the spread of technology and innovation, driving productivity improvements and technological advancements worldwide.
6. 
   
7. Cultural Exchange: Greater interconnectedness has allowed for cultural exchange and appreciation of diversity among nations.
8. 
   
9. Foreign Direct Investment (FDI): Globalisation attracts foreign investment, which can lead to the development of industries and infrastructure in host countries.

Costs of Globalisation:

1. Income Inequality: Globalisation has been associated with growing income inequality within countries, where certain segments of society benefit more than others.
2. 
   
3. Job Displacement: The relocation of industries to countries with lower production costs can result in job losses in some regions, leading to structural unemployment.
4. 
   
5. Environmental Impact: Increased global economic activities have raised concerns about environmental degradation and unsustainable resource consumption.
6. 
   
7. Dependency on Global Markets: Developing countries may become overly dependent on international markets, making them vulnerable to external economic shocks.
8. 
   
9. Financial Instability: Interconnected global financial markets can lead to financial crises, as demonstrated in the 2008 global financial crisis.
10. 
    
11. Cultural Homogenisation: Some argue that globalisation may lead to the erosion of unique cultural identities as more dominant cultures influence others.

Evaluating the Costs and Benefits: The costs and benefits of globalisation are not distributed equally among all countries and individuals. Developed economies with advanced industries tend to benefit more from globalisation due to their competitive advantages. Meanwhile, developing countries may face challenges and vulnerabilities, particularly in terms of income inequality and the risk of deindustrialisation.

Policymakers need to address the downsides of globalisation by implementing measures that mitigate negative impacts and ensure that the benefits are more inclusive. This can include investing in education and skills development, social safety nets, and sustainable environmental practices.

Overall, the evaluation of globalisation's costs and benefits is context-dependent and requires a nuanced understanding of the specific challenges and opportunities faced by different countries and societies. Balancing global integration with domestic development goals is essential for harnessing the potential benefits of globalisation while mitigating its negative consequences.

---

Major Export Sectors in the UK: The UK has a diverse range of export sectors, but some of the major ones include:

1. Financial Services: The UK is a global financial hub, with London being a prominent center for financial services, including banking, insurance, and asset management.

2. 
   

3. Manufacturing: The UK exports various manufactured goods, including automobiles, aerospace products, pharmaceuticals, and machinery.

4. 
   

5. Oil and Gas: The UK is a significant exporter of oil and gas products, benefiting from its North Sea oil reserves.

6. 
   

7. Professional Services: The UK exports professional services such as legal, accounting, and consulting services to countries around the world.

8. 
   

9. Creative Industries: The UK is a major exporter of creative goods and services, including films, music, video games, and television programs.

10. 
    

11. Pharmaceuticals and Life Sciences: The UK exports pharmaceutical products and medical equipment, driven by its strong research and development capabilities.

Evaluation of the Benefits of an Increasingly Integrated World Economy to the UK: An increasingly integrated world economy, characterized by globalisation, has both benefits and challenges for the UK:

Benefits:

1. Access to Larger Markets: Integration allows UK businesses to access larger international markets, expanding their customer base and revenue potential.

2. 
   

3. Economies of Scale: Increased trade and cross-border investment can lead to economies of scale, reducing production costs and increasing efficiency.

4. 
   

5. Enhanced Innovation: Integration fosters knowledge-sharing and innovation as the UK can access cutting-edge technology and ideas from other countries.

6. 
   

7. Foreign Investment: An integrated world economy attracts foreign direct investment, which brings in capital, technology, and expertise to the UK.

8. 
   

9. Diversification of Exports: The UK can reduce reliance on domestic markets by diversifying its exports to multiple countries, reducing vulnerability to domestic economic fluctuations.

10. 
    

11. Cultural Exchange: Globalisation promotes cultural exchange, leading to a richer, more diverse cultural landscape in the UK.

Challenges:

1. Competition: Increased integration exposes UK industries to heightened global competition, which may negatively impact certain sectors.

2. 
   

3. Income Inequality: Globalisation can exacerbate income inequality, as some segments of society may benefit more than others.

4. 
   

5. Job Displacement: Some UK workers may face job displacement due to international competition and outsourcing.

6. 
   

7. Environmental Impact: Globalisation can lead to increased environmental pressures as trade and transportation volumes grow.

8. 
   

9. Financial Instability: Integration can result in financial contagion, as demonstrated in the 2008 global financial crisis.

Overall Evaluation: An increasingly integrated world economy has been beneficial to the UK in many ways, particularly by opening up new markets, attracting investment, and fostering innovation. The UK's status as a global financial and business hub has been strengthened by its participation in the global economy.

However, challenges such as income inequality, job displacement, and environmental concerns need to be addressed through appropriate policies. By focusing on inclusive growth, investing in education and skills development, and implementing sustainable practices, the UK can reap the benefits of an integrated world economy while mitigating its negative effects. A balanced approach that considers the welfare of all citizens and promotes sustainable development is essential for maximizing the benefits of globalisation in the UK.

---

The World Trade Organization (WTO) is an international organization that deals with the global rules of trade between nations. It was established on January 1, 1995, and succeeded the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT). The WTO operates as a forum for member countries to negotiate and set trade rules, resolve disputes, and ensure the smooth functioning of international trade.

Role in Policing Trade Agreements: The WTO plays a crucial role in policing trade agreements through various mechanisms:

1. Dispute Settlement Mechanism: One of the primary functions of the WTO is its dispute settlement system. When member countries believe that another member is violating WTO trade rules, they can bring a dispute to the WTO's Dispute Settlement Body (DSB). The DSB hears and adjudicates disputes, ensuring that countries comply with their trade commitments and do not resort to unilateral protectionist measures.

2. 
   

3. Trade Policy Reviews: The WTO conducts regular Trade Policy Reviews (TPRs) of member countries. During these reviews, the trade policies and practices of each member are examined, promoting transparency and providing an opportunity for constructive feedback and recommendations.

4. 
   

5. Monitoring and Surveillance: The WTO continuously monitors global trade policies and developments. It helps identify potential trade barriers and encourages members to abide by agreed-upon rules, thereby fostering a fair and predictable trading environment.

6. 
   

7. Notification Requirements: Member countries are required to notify the WTO about their trade-related measures, such as tariffs, subsidies, and technical regulations. This promotes transparency and ensures that other countries are informed about potential impacts on their trade interests.

Role in Trade Negotiations: The WTO also plays a significant role in trade negotiations:

1. Multilateral Trade Negotiations: The WTO hosts multilateral negotiations among member countries to address various trade issues, such as reducing tariffs, eliminating trade barriers, and liberalizing trade in specific sectors. These negotiations aim to achieve mutually beneficial outcomes for all participating countries.

2. 
   

3. Accession Negotiations: The WTO facilitates negotiations with countries seeking to join the organization. Prospective members must negotiate and make specific commitments to adhere to WTO rules and regulations.

4. 
   

5. Trade Facilitation Agreement: The WTO reached a landmark Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA) in 2013, which aims to streamline and simplify customs procedures to expedite trade and reduce trade costs for businesses.

Overall, the WTO acts as a neutral platform for member countries to engage in trade negotiations, resolve disputes, and ensure compliance with trade agreements. By providing a rules-based framework for international trade, the WTO contributes to the stability and predictability of the global trading system, promoting economic growth and development worldwide. However, like any international organization, the WTO faces challenges in reconciling the diverse interests of its member countries and addressing complex and evolving trade issues in a rapidly changing global economic landscape.

---

1. More Economically Developed Countries (MEDCs): Refers to countries with advanced industrialization, high levels of economic development, and relatively high standards of living.

2. 
   

3. Less Economically Developed Countries (LEDCs): Refers to countries with lower levels of industrialization, lower income levels, and often facing socio-economic challenges.

4. 
   

5. Emerging Economies: Refers to countries that are transitioning from low-income to middle-income status and experiencing rapid economic growth and development.

Economic Problems Facing MEDCs:

1. Unemployment and Underemployment: Even in advanced economies, cyclical or structural unemployment can be a persistent issue. Technological advancements and changes in industries can lead to job displacement, creating challenges in providing employment opportunities.

2. 
   

3. Income Inequality: MEDCs may experience significant income disparities between the rich and the poor. This can result from factors such as differences in education, skills, and access to resources.

4. 
   

5. Aging Population: Many MEDCs face the challenge of an aging population, leading to increased demand for healthcare and pension systems, which can strain public finances.

6. 
   

7. Environmental Concerns: Developed countries often face environmental problems due to high consumption levels and industrial activities, such as pollution, climate change, and resource depletion.

Economic Problems Facing LEDCs:

1. Poverty and Lack of Basic Services: LEDCs often struggle with widespread poverty and inadequate access to essential services such as education, healthcare, and clean water.

2. 
   

3. Infrastructure Deficiencies: Many LEDCs have limited infrastructure, hindering economic development and trade. Insufficient transportation, energy, and communication networks can hamper economic growth.

4. 
   

5. Debt Burden: LEDCs may accumulate substantial external debts, making it challenging to finance development projects and service debt obligations.

6. 
   

7. Political Instability: Political instability and governance issues can hinder investment and economic growth in LEDCs.

Economic Problems Facing Emerging Economies:

1. Income Disparities: Rapid economic growth in emerging economies can lead to income inequalities and disparities between urban and rural areas.

2. 
   

3. Currency Volatility: Emerging economies may face currency volatility due to external shocks or speculative activities, impacting their trade and overall economic stability.

4. 
   

5. Infrastructure Development: Despite growth, many emerging economies require significant investment in infrastructure to sustain their development trajectory.

6. 
   

7. Corruption and Governance Challenges: Weak governance and corruption can hinder economic progress and deter foreign investment.

Examples:

1. MEDC Example: The United States faces challenges in reducing income inequality, providing affordable healthcare, and transitioning to a greener economy to address environmental concerns.

2. LEDC Example: Sub-Saharan African countries often confront poverty, lack of access to education and healthcare, and inadequate infrastructure, impeding their economic development.

3. Emerging Economy Example: India's rapid economic growth has led to income disparities between urban and rural areas, and the country must invest in infrastructure to maintain its growth momentum.

Each category of countries faces unique economic challenges that require tailored policies and strategies for sustainable development and inclusive growth. Governments and policymakers need to address these issues proactively to ensure socio-economic progress and stability.