How to build a Global Currency

From The Economist

Seventy years ago the Indian rupee was often found a long way from home. After India gained independence from Britain, the currency remained in use in sheikhdoms across the Arabian Sea. Until as late as 1970, some employed the Gulf rupee, a currency issued by India’s central bank.

Today the picture is rather different. The rupee accounts for less than 2% of international-currency transactions, even though the Indian economy is the world’s fifth-largest. Narendra Modi, India’s prime minister, would like to see the currency span the globe once again. Speaking at the 90th anniversary of the Reserve Bank of India on April 1st, Mr Modi told the central bank’s policymakers to focus on making the rupee more accessible. Historically, however, national leaders have been a lot more likely to express enthusiasm for the idea of making their currency a global one than to enact the reforms required to do so.

Although the American dollar is the undisputed king of currencies, there are many with a global role of their own. The euro, the British pound, the Swiss franc, and the dollars of Australia, Canada, Hong Kong and Singapore are all examples. These currencies are found in foreign reserves and private portfolios worldwide, and used for both trade and financial transactions. In theory, there is no reason why the rupee should not join the illustrious group.

Having a widely used currency brings sizeable benefits. Demand from overseas investors lowers financing costs for domestic companies, which are no longer compelled to borrow in foreign currencies. Such demand also reduces exchange-rate risks for exporters and importers, who do not need to convert currencies so often when trading, and enables the government to reduce the size of its foreign-exchange reserves.

Some of the foundation stones of an international currency are being laid in India. The country now has assets that foreigners want to buy, making the rupee a potential store of value overseas. In September JPMorgan Chase, a bank, announced that it would include Indian government bonds in its emerging-market index. Bloomberg, a data provider, took the same decision last month. The explosive performance of the country’s stocks, which are up by 37% in dollar terms over the past year, has piqued global interest.

The rupee is also increasingly a unit of account and a medium of exchange for foreigners. Banks from 22 countries have been permitted to open special rupee-denominated accounts, without the usual exchange limits. In August India made its first rupee payment for oil, to the Abu Dhabi National Oil Company.

Yet China shows how far India has to go. Although Chinese policymakers have been trying to make the yuan a global currency for more than a decade, it still accounts for less than 3% of international trades made via swift, a payments network, outside the euro zone, despite the fact that China accounts for 17% of global gdp. Moreover, 80% of such international yuan transactions occur in Hong Kong. China’s relatively closed capital account, which prevents investments from flowing freely across its borders, is the main obstacle to wider use of its currency. India’s capital account is less closed than it once was, but is still far more sheltered than that of any of the countries with a global currency.

Japan provides a better example. In 1970 it accounted for 7% of global gdp—more than the 4% it does now—and its companies were beginning to make a mark abroad. But the yen was a nonentity. That changed over the following decade: in 1970, 1% of Japan’s exports were invoiced in yen; by the early 1980s, 40% were. In 1989 the yen made up 28% of all foreign-exchange transactions. It still accounts for 16% today.

To make the leap to global-currency status, Japan’s leaders had to transform the country’s economy. They allowed foreigners to hold a wide range of assets, deregulated big financial institutions, and peeled back controls on capital flows and interest rates. These changes disrupted Japan’s export-oriented economic model, and undermined the power of the country’s bureaucrats.

Changes just as far-reaching—and uncomfortable—will be required for any country that now wants to join the top table. Few seem to have the stomach for them at present. Indeed, without American pressure and the threat of tariffs, Japan itself might not have made such reforms. America is not about to lean on India in the same way. The desire for change will have to come from within.

A Level Economics: Practice Questions on Exchange Rates

In a fixed exchange rate system, the central bank or government intervenes in the foreign exchange market to:

1. a) Increase interest rates b) Devalue the domestic currency c) Maintain a constant exchange rate d) Allow the exchange rate to float freely

   Solution: c) Maintain a constant exchange rate

2. 
   

3. The exchange rate in a floating exchange rate system is primarily determined by: a) Central bank interventions b) Market forces of demand and supply c) Government policies d) Trade imbalances

   Solution: b) Market forces of demand and supply

4. 
   

5. In a managed exchange rate system, the central bank occasionally intervenes in the foreign exchange market to: a) Fix the exchange rate b) Allow the exchange rate to float freely c) Influence the exchange rate within a certain range d) Prevent any exchange rate fluctuations

   Solution: c) Influence the exchange rate within a certain range

6. 
   

7. What happens to the value of a currency in a free-float system when the demand for that currency exceeds its supply? a) The value appreciates b) The value depreciates c) The value remains constant d) The value fluctuates randomly

   Solution: a) The value appreciates

8. 
   

9. Which factor does NOT contribute to the demand for a currency? a) Exports b) Capital outflows c) Capital inflows d) Investments

   Solution: b) Capital outflows

10. 
    

11. In a free-float exchange rate system, what happens when a country imports goods and services from other countries? a) The supply of its currency increases b) The supply of its currency decreases c) The value of its currency appreciates d) The value of its currency depreciates

    Solution: a) The supply of its currency increases

12. 
    

13. What factor can cause a country's currency to appreciate in value? a) Higher interest rates b) Large-scale quantitative easing c) Trade deficits d) Global uncertainty

    Solution: a) Higher interest rates

14. 
    

15. Which policy objective may be affected by exchange rate changes in a country with an inflation targeting regime? a) Economic growth b) Trade balance c) Inflation d) Exchange rate stability

    Solution: c) Inflation

16. 
    

17. In a floating exchange rate system, how can a weaker currency impact a country's trade balance? a) Improve the trade balance by making exports cheaper b) Worsen the trade balance by making imports cheaper c) Have no effect on the trade balance d) Decrease the demand for exports

    Solution: a) Improve the trade balance by making exports cheaper

18. 
    

19. How can a currency depreciation impact a firm with foreign debt? a) Reduce the firm's foreign debt burden b) Increase the firm's foreign debt burden c) Have no effect on the firm's foreign debt d) Reduce the firm's export competitiveness

    Solution: b) Increase the firm's foreign debt burden

1. The current exchange rate between the US Dollar (USD) and the Euro (EUR) is 1 USD = 0.85 EUR. If you exchange 500 USD into EUR, how much EUR will you receive? a) 425 EUR b) 500 EUR c) 425 USD d) 589 EUR

Solution: To convert USD to EUR, we multiply the amount in USD by the exchange rate. 500 USD * 0.85 EUR/USD = 425 EUR

Correct answer: a) 425 EUR

2. The exchange rate between the British Pound (GBP) and the Japanese Yen (JPY) is 1 GBP = 150 JPY. If you have 10,000 JPY and want to convert it to GBP, how much GBP will you receive? a) 0.0667 GBP b) 66.67 GBP c) 150 GBP d) 15,000 GBP

Solution: To convert JPY to GBP, we divide the amount in JPY by the exchange rate. 10,000 JPY / 150 JPY/GBP = 66.67 GBP

Correct answer: b) 66.67 GBP

3. The central bank of a country decides to devalue its currency by 10%. If the current exchange rate is 1 USD = 100 units of the domestic currency, what will be the new exchange rate after the devaluation? a) 1 USD = 110 units b) 1 USD = 100 units c) 1 USD = 90 units d) 1 USD = 10 units

Solution: To calculate the new exchange rate after the devaluation, we need to reduce the value of the domestic currency by 10%. New exchange rate = 100 units - (10% of 100 units) = 100 units - 10 units = 90 units

Correct answer: c) 1 USD = 90 units

4. The Euro to Swiss Franc (CHF) exchange rate has increased from 1 EUR = 1.10 CHF to 1 EUR = 1.25 CHF. By what percentage has the Euro appreciated against the Swiss Franc? a) 12.5% b) 13.6% c) 14.8% d) 25%

Solution: To calculate the percentage appreciation, we use the formula: Percentage appreciation = ((New rate - Old rate) / Old rate) * 100 Percentage appreciation = ((1.25 CHF - 1.10 CHF) / 1.10 CHF) * 100 Percentage appreciation = (0.15 CHF / 1.10 CHF) * 100 Percentage appreciation = 13.6%

Correct answer: b) 13.6%

5. A tourist from Country A visits Country B and converts 1,000 units of Country A's currency to Country B's currency at an exchange rate of 1 Country A unit = 0.75 Country B units. The tourist spends all the money and converts the remaining Country B currency back to Country A currency at an exchange rate of 1 Country A unit = 0.80 Country B units. How much Country A currency does the tourist get after converting back the money? a) 750 units b) 800 units c) 933.33 units d) 1,066.67 units

Solution: First, we calculate how much Country B currency the tourist receives in Country B. Amount in Country B currency = 1,000 units (Country A currency) * 0.75 Country B units / 1 Country A unit = 750 units (Country B currency)

Now, the tourist converts the 750 units of Country B currency back to Country A currency using the new exchange rate. Amount in Country A currency = 750 units (Country B currency) * 1 Country A unit / 0.80 Country B units = 937.5 units (Country A currency)

Correct answer: c) 933.33 units (rounded to two decimal places)

---

Long Answer Questions

1. Analyze the advantages and disadvantages of a fixed exchange rate system compared to a floating exchange rate system, considering factors such as monetary policy flexibility, trade balance adjustments, and exchange rate stability.

2. 
   

3. Evaluate the impact of a managed exchange rate system on a country's economy. Discuss the effectiveness of occasional central bank interventions in stabilizing the currency while allowing it to float within a certain range. Consider how this system addresses trade imbalances and speculative trading.

4. 
   

5. Assess the implications of a country's currency depreciation on its domestic economy and international trade. Analyze how a weaker currency affects export-oriented industries, import-dependent sectors, and inflation levels, and discuss possible policy responses to manage these effects.

6. 
   

7. Analyze the role of interest rates in influencing exchange rate fluctuations. Evaluate the relationship between higher interest rates, capital inflows, and currency appreciation, and discuss the potential challenges a country may face when adopting such a policy to attract foreign investment.

8. 
   

9. Evaluate the impact of major global events, such as the COVID-19 pandemic or geopolitical tensions, on exchange rates and currency movements. Analyze how safe-haven demand, quantitative easing measures, and changes in trade flows can affect the exchange rates of specific currencies and their implications on international trade dynamics.

A Level Economics 98: The European Union

The European Union (EU) is a unique example of both a political and economic union. It is important to note that the EU's structure and level of integration differ significantly from other countries like the USA, China, and India.

1. Political Union:

   • The EU is a political union in the sense that it aims to create a framework for cooperation and decision-making among its member states on various political matters. This includes setting common policies in areas such as trade, environment, immigration, security, and foreign affairs.
   • 
     
   • The EU has its own political institutions, such as the European Commission, the European Parliament, and the European Council, which work together to shape and implement EU policies.
   • 
     
   • Decision-making within the EU often involves complex negotiations and compromises among member states to accommodate their diverse interests and concerns.
   • 
     

   Comparison:

   • 
     
   • In contrast, the USA is a federal political union, where individual states have a degree of sovereignty, and powers are divided between the federal government and state governments. The federal government has authority over matters such as foreign policy, defense, and trade, while state governments have jurisdiction over local issues.
   • 
     
   • China operates as a unitary state with a strong central government that exercises significant control over regional governments. The Communist Party of China holds the ultimate authority and has decision-making power over key national policies and issues.
   • 
     
   • India is a federal political union similar to the USA, where powers are divided between the central government and state governments. The central government has authority over matters specified in the Union List, while state governments have authority over matters listed in the State List.
   • 
     

2. Economic Union:

   • 
     
   • The EU is an economic union as well, with a focus on promoting economic integration and cooperation among its member states. This includes the creation of a single market, the adoption of a common currency (Eurozone countries), and the establishment of common economic policies.
   • 
     
   • The EU's single market allows for the free movement of goods, services, capital, and labor across member states, fostering economic growth and efficiency.
   • 
     
   • The Eurozone countries share a common currency, the euro, which is managed by the European Central Bank. This allows for easier trade and financial transactions within the Eurozone.
   • 
     

   Comparison:

   • 
     
   • The USA has a common currency, the US dollar, which is used across all states, contributing to economic integration and trade efficiency within the country.
   • 
     
   • China has a more centralized economic system, with a national currency, the Chinese yuan (Renminbi), and a strong central government that plays a significant role in economic planning and decision-making.
   • 
     
   • India operates with a common currency, the Indian rupee, across all states, facilitating economic transactions and trade within the country.

Overall, while the EU shares some similarities with other political and economic unions, its structure and level of integration are distinct, reflecting the diverse needs and interests of its member states. The EU's model of cooperation and governance may serve as a case study for other countries or regions seeking to enhance political and economic integration while respecting national sovereignty. However, each union operates within its unique political, cultural, and historical context, leading to differences in their organizational structures and functioning.

---

Advantages of EU Membership:

1. Access to a Large Market: EU membership provides access to a vast single market with over 500 million consumers, offering opportunities for trade and economic growth.

2. 
   

3. Free Movement of Goods, Services, and Labor: EU membership allows for the free movement of goods, services, and people within the member states, promoting economic integration and labor mobility.

4. 
   

5. Increased Foreign Direct Investment (FDI): Being part of the EU attracts higher levels of FDI due to the larger market and regulatory stability.

6. 
   

7. Economic Growth and Development: EU membership has historically been associated with higher economic growth and development for member states.

8. 
   

9. Common Currency (Eurozone): For Eurozone countries, using the euro as a common currency eliminates exchange rate risks and simplifies cross-border transactions.

10. 
    

11. Shared Political Objectives: EU member states collaborate on various political issues, such as human rights, climate change, and regional security, enhancing their collective influence on the global stage.

12. 
    

13. Regulatory Harmonization: EU regulations and standards create a level playing field for businesses across member states, promoting fair competition and consumer protection.

Disadvantages of EU Membership:

1. Loss of Sovereignty: EU member states must comply with EU laws and regulations, which can result in a loss of national sovereignty in certain areas.

2. 
   

3. Financial Contributions: Member states are required to contribute financially to the EU budget, which can be a burden for some countries, particularly net contributors.

4. 
   

5. Bureaucracy and Decision-Making: The EU's decision-making process can be complex and time-consuming, leading to bureaucracy and delays in implementing policies.

6. 
   

7. Regional Disparities: Some regions within member states may not benefit equally from EU membership, leading to regional economic disparities.

8. 
   

9. Loss of Control over Monetary Policy (Eurozone): Eurozone countries lose the ability to control their individual monetary policies, as the European Central Bank sets the interest rates for the entire Eurozone.

10. 
    

11. Migration and Security Concerns: Free movement of people can lead to concerns over immigration and security issues, especially during times of crisis.

Prospective Member Advantages:

1. Economic Integration: Joining the EU provides access to a larger market and potential economic growth.

2. 
   

3. Strengthened Political Ties: EU membership fosters stronger political ties and cooperation with other member states.

Prospective Member Disadvantages:

1. Adoption of Acquis Communautaire: Prospective members must adopt EU laws and regulations, which can be challenging and require significant adjustments.

2. 
   

3. Financial Contributions: New members will be required to make financial contributions to the EU budget.

4. 
   

5. Harmonization of Policies: Prospective members must align their policies with EU standards and regulations.

Overall, the advantages and disadvantages of EU membership vary depending on the specific circumstances and objectives of each member state or prospective member. While EU membership offers numerous benefits, it also requires sacrifices and entails certain challenges that must be carefully considered and weighed by countries seeking to join or remain within the EU.

---

The continuous expansion of the European Union (EU) can have both benefits and challenges for both existing members and new members. Here, we will evaluate these aspects:

Benefits for Existing Members:

1. Economic Advantages: Enlargement increases the size of the EU's single market, leading to more significant trade opportunities and economies of scale. This can foster economic growth and enhance the competitiveness of existing member countries.

2. 
   

3. Geopolitical Strength: A larger EU can have more influence on the global stage, allowing it to negotiate more effectively with other economic blocs and international organizations.

4. 
   

5. Pooling Resources: With the inclusion of new members, the EU can pool resources, such as finances and expertise, to address common challenges like security, migration, and climate change.

6. 
   

7. Cultural Exchange: Expanding the EU allows for cultural exchange and promotes understanding among different European nations, fostering greater unity and cooperation.

Challenges for Existing Members:

1. Integration Challenges: As the EU expands, the process of integrating new members can be complex and may require significant efforts to harmonize laws, regulations, and economic policies.

2. 
   

3. Financial Burden: The integration of new, often less developed, members may require financial contributions from existing member countries to support their economic development and convergence.

4. 
   

5. Decision-Making Complexity: With more member states, reaching consensus on key policy issues may become more challenging, potentially slowing down decision-making processes.

Benefits for New Members:

1. Economic Gains: Joining the EU can provide access to the single market, attracting foreign investments and boosting trade opportunities for new members.

2. 
   

3. Political Stability: Membership in the EU offers a framework for political stability and democratic governance, which can be particularly valuable for countries with a history of instability.

4. 
   

5. Institutional Support: New members gain access to various EU institutions, resources, and expertise, which can help them modernize and align with European standards.

Challenges for New Members:

1. Convergence Challenges: New members may face economic challenges in meeting EU economic criteria, leading to the need for significant reforms and adjustments.

2. 
   

3. Loss of Sovereignty: Membership in the EU requires adherence to EU laws and regulations, which may result in some loss of sovereignty for new members.

4. 
   

5. Financial Obligations: New members must contribute financially to the EU's budget and may initially receive less in funding than they contribute.

Overall, the benefits and challenges of EU expansion depend on the specific circumstances of each country and the political will of both existing and new members to work together to achieve common goals. Careful consideration of the economic, political, and social factors is essential to ensure that the expansion is mutually beneficial and fosters further integration, stability, and prosperity for all member states.

---

The Economic and Monetary Union (EMU):

The Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) is a core component of the European Union (EU) that aims to integrate the economies and monetary policies of its member countries. It was established to promote economic stability, facilitate trade and investment, and foster closer economic cooperation among its members.

Structure of the EMU:

1. Single Currency: The most prominent feature of the EMU is the adoption of a single currency known as the euro. As of 2021, 19 out of the 27 EU member states have adopted the euro as their official currency.

2. 
   

3. European Central Bank (ECB): The ECB is the central institution responsible for monetary policy within the eurozone. It is based in Frankfurt, Germany, and is tasked with maintaining price stability and supporting sustainable economic growth.

4. 
   

5. Monetary Policy Coordination: Member countries participating in the EMU transfer their national monetary policymaking authority to the ECB. The ECB's primary objective is to keep inflation close to but below 2% over the medium term.

6. 
   

7. Fiscal Policy Coordination: While fiscal policies (government spending and taxation) are mainly under the purview of individual member states, the EMU encourages coordination to ensure sound fiscal management and avoid excessive deficits.

8. 
   

9. European Stability and Growth Pact (SGP): The SGP sets rules and guidelines for fiscal discipline within the eurozone. It requires member countries to maintain their budget deficits below 3% of GDP and government debt below 60% of GDP.

Functioning of the EMU:

The EMU operates on the principle of economic convergence, where member states aim to align their economic policies and structures to promote stability and balanced growth. Countries within the EMU are expected to pursue responsible fiscal policies, ensure price stability, and implement structural reforms to enhance competitiveness.

Benefits of the EMU:

1. Price Stability: A single currency promotes price stability, reducing currency exchange risks and uncertainties for businesses and consumers.

2. 
   

3. Enhanced Trade: The euro's adoption simplifies cross-border transactions, leading to increased trade and investment flows among member countries.

4. 
   

5. Lower Transaction Costs: The elimination of currency conversion costs and exchange rate fluctuations benefits businesses engaged in trade within the eurozone.

6. 
   

7. Monetary Integration: A unified monetary policy allows for effective management of monetary conditions and interest rates across the eurozone.

Challenges of the EMU:

1. Divergent Economies: The eurozone comprises countries with different economic structures and levels of development, making it challenging to adopt a one-size-fits-all monetary policy.

2. 
   

3. Fiscal Coordination: Limited fiscal coordination among member states can hinder effective responses to economic crises and asymmetric shocks.

4. 
   

5. Sovereignty Concerns: Some member states may feel that transferring monetary policy authority to the ECB limits their ability to address specific domestic economic challenges.

Overall, the EMU represents a unique experiment in monetary integration and economic cooperation. While it offers several benefits, its success depends on effective coordination of fiscal and monetary policies, structural reforms, and efforts to address economic divergences among member states.