A Level Economics 94: Exchange Rate Policy

Influencing Exchange Rates in a Managed Float System:

In a managed float system, monetary authorities have some control over the exchange rate, but they do not fix it at a specific value as in a fixed exchange rate system. Instead, they intervene in the foreign exchange market to influence the exchange rate and stabilize it within a certain range. The key methods used by central banks and monetary authorities to influence the exchange rate are as follows:

1. Foreign Exchange Market Intervention: Central banks can actively buy or sell their domestic currency in the foreign exchange market. When they want to weaken their currency, they sell their currency and buy foreign currencies, increasing the supply of their currency in the market. This increased supply drives down the exchange rate. On the other hand, when they want to strengthen their currency, they buy their currency and sell foreign currencies, reducing the supply of their currency in the market and leading to an appreciation of the currency.

2. Interest Rate Policy: Central banks can use interest rates as a tool to influence capital flows and demand for their currency. Higher interest rates can attract foreign investors seeking better returns, increasing the demand for the domestic currency and leading to its appreciation. Conversely, lower interest rates can reduce demand for the currency, leading to its depreciation.

3. Foreign Exchange Reserves Management: Central banks maintain foreign exchange reserves, which they can use to stabilize the exchange rate during times of excessive volatility. By buying or selling foreign currencies from their reserves, central banks can influence the exchange rate.

4. Forward Guidance: Central banks can also influence the exchange rate through forward guidance, which involves signaling their future monetary policy actions. Market participants may adjust their expectations based on central bank communication, impacting the exchange rate.

Impact of Exchange Rate Changes on Terms of Trade: Exchange rate changes can have significant effects on a country's terms of trade, which is the ratio of export prices to import prices. The impact depends on the direction of the exchange rate change:

1. Currency Depreciation: When a country's currency depreciates, its export prices become relatively cheaper in foreign markets. This can lead to an increase in export revenues as foreign buyers find the country's goods and services more attractive due to their lower prices. However, import prices become more expensive, potentially leading to higher costs for imported goods and potentially fueling inflation.

2. Currency Appreciation: On the other hand, when a country's currency appreciates, its export prices become relatively more expensive for foreign buyers. This can result in a decline in export revenues as foreign demand may decrease. However, import prices become cheaper, benefiting domestic consumers and businesses reliant on imported inputs, which can potentially help keep inflation in check.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Holding Exchange Rates Artificially:

1. Advantages:

   a. Export Competitiveness: By keeping the exchange rate undervalued, a country's goods and services can become more competitive in international markets, which can boost export volumes and support domestic industries.

   b. Current Account Balance: An undervalued exchange rate can improve the country's current account balance by promoting exports and reducing imports, potentially leading to a reduction in trade deficits.

2. Disadvantages:

   a. Inflationary Pressures: Artificially keeping the exchange rate low can lead to inflationary pressures as the cost of imports rises, impacting domestic consumers' purchasing power.

   b. Imports and Input Costs: An undervalued exchange rate can increase the cost of imported goods and raw materials for domestic businesses, potentially affecting their profitability.

   c. Speculative Pressure: Artificially managing exchange rates can attract speculative activities in the foreign exchange market, leading to financial market instability and creating risks for the economy.

The Marshall Lerner Condition and J Curve:

The Marshall Lerner condition states that a depreciation (or appreciation) of a country's currency will improve the trade balance if the sum of the price elasticities of demand for exports and imports is greater than one. In other words, if demand for exports and imports is responsive to changes in their prices, a change in the exchange rate can lead to a significant impact on trade balances.

The J curve effect refers to the short-term worsening of a country's trade balance immediately after a currency depreciation. It occurs because the demand for exports and imports may be relatively inelastic in the short term, meaning that changes in prices do not have an immediate effect on demand. As a result, in the short term, a currency depreciation may lead to a worsening trade balance. However, over time, as demand becomes more elastic and adjusts to price changes, the trade balance may improve.

Conclusion: In a managed float exchange rate system, monetary authorities have some control over the exchange rate through interventions and other policy measures. Exchange rate changes can have significant effects on the economy, including impacts on trade balances, inflation, and competitiveness. While managing exchange rates can offer advantages such as export competitiveness, there are also risks and disadvantages associated with artificially influencing currency values. Policymakers must carefully consider the trade-offs and potential side effects when implementing exchange rate policies.

A Level Economics 91: Interest Rates, Exchange Rates and QE

The relationship between interest rates and exchange rates is an important aspect of international economics. Interest rates, set by central banks, influence the cost of borrowing and the return on savings, while exchange rates determine the relative value of one currency against another. The interaction between these two factors can have significant implications for international trade, investment, and overall economic conditions.

Interest Rates and Exchange Rates Relationship:

1. Interest Rate Differential: One of the primary drivers of exchange rates is the interest rate differential between two countries. When one country's interest rates are higher than another's, it creates an incentive for investors to hold assets denominated in the currency of the higher-interest-rate country. This increased demand for the currency leads to its appreciation relative to the other currency.

   Example: Suppose the United States has a higher interest rate than Japan. Investors seeking higher returns may choose to invest in US assets, leading to an increase in demand for US dollars (USD) and a corresponding appreciation of the USD against the Japanese yen (JPY).

2. Capital Flows: Changes in interest rates influence capital flows between countries. Higher interest rates attract foreign investors seeking better returns, leading to an inflow of foreign capital. This influx of capital drives up demand for the domestic currency and contributes to its appreciation.

   Example: If the European Central Bank raises interest rates, it may attract foreign investors to hold euro-denominated assets, causing the euro (EUR) to strengthen against other currencies.

3. Carry Trade: Lower interest rates in one country relative to another may encourage investors to engage in carry trades. In a carry trade, investors borrow in a low-interest-rate currency and invest in higher-yielding assets in another currency. This can result in increased demand for the higher-yielding currency and lead to its appreciation.

   Example: When the Bank of England maintains lower interest rates compared to Australia, investors may borrow in British pounds (GBP) and invest in Australian dollars (AUD) to earn higher interest on Australian assets, leading to an appreciation of the AUD.

4. Monetary Policy Impact: Interest rate changes influence inflation expectations and monetary policy stances. Higher interest rates may be used to combat inflation, signaling a tightening monetary policy, which can strengthen the currency. Conversely, lower interest rates can signal accommodative monetary policy and lead to currency depreciation.

   Example: If the Reserve Bank of New Zealand raises interest rates to control inflation, it may attract investors looking for higher returns, leading to an appreciation of the New Zealand dollar (NZD).

Extent of Impact:

The extent to which changes in interest rates affect the exchange rate depends on several factors:

1. Economic Conditions: Interest rate changes may have a stronger impact when economies are stable and interest rates are the primary driver of capital flows. In times of economic uncertainty or crises, other factors may overshadow interest rate effects.

2. Global Factors: External events, such as geopolitical tensions or global economic developments, can influence exchange rates independently of interest rate changes.

3. Market Sentiment: Investor sentiment and expectations play a significant role in exchange rate movements. Even if interest rates change, market participants' perception of economic conditions can lead to different outcomes.

4. Interest Rate Policy Expectations: Central bank communication about future interest rate policies can affect exchange rates. Clarity and consistency in messaging can influence market expectations and reduce exchange rate volatility.

Conclusion:

The relationship between interest rates and exchange rates is complex and multi-faceted. Interest rates can influence exchange rates through interest rate differentials, capital flows, carry trades, and monetary policy impacts. However, exchange rate movements are also affected by various other factors and market dynamics. Central banks must carefully consider these interactions when using interest rates as a tool to manage exchange rate fluctuations and overall macroeconomic conditions.

---

Quantitative Easing (QE):

Quantitative Easing is a monetary policy tool used by central banks to stimulate the economy and increase money supply. It involves the purchase of financial assets, typically long-term government bonds and other securities, from the market by the central bank. The goal of QE is to lower long-term interest rates, boost lending, encourage borrowing, and support economic growth when conventional monetary policy measures, such as cutting short-term interest rates, become less effective.

Role of QE within the Financial System and How it Works:

1. Lowering Long-Term Interest Rates: By purchasing long-term assets, the central bank increases their demand, driving up their prices, and consequently, lowering their yields or interest rates. Lower long-term interest rates influence a wide range of borrowing and lending rates in the economy, making credit more affordable for households and businesses.

2. Increasing Money Supply: The central bank creates new money to purchase financial assets. This injection of money into the economy increases the money supply and can help to stimulate spending and investment.

3. Supporting Financial Markets: QE can provide liquidity and stabilize financial markets during times of stress or crisis. It can improve investor sentiment and reduce risk premiums, supporting asset prices and reducing market volatility.

4. Inflation Targeting: In economies with persistently low inflation, QE is employed to raise inflation expectations and achieve the central bank's inflation target.

Impact and Risks of QE:

Positive Impact:

1. Stimulating Economic Activity: QE can encourage borrowing and spending, which can stimulate economic growth, increase employment, and reduce unemployment.

2. Asset Price Support: QE can boost the prices of financial assets, including stocks and bonds, improving investors' wealth and confidence.

3. Fighting Deflation: QE can be an effective tool to combat deflationary pressures by increasing the money supply and promoting spending.

Risks:

1. Asset Price Bubbles: Prolonged QE and low-interest-rate policies may lead to excessive risk-taking and asset price bubbles, potentially creating financial instability.

2. Inflationary Pressures: If the increased money supply leads to excessive spending, it can result in inflationary pressures.

3. Unequal Impact: The benefits of QE may not be evenly distributed, benefiting asset owners and financial institutions more than the broader population.

Reversal of QE:

As the economy improves and inflation rises, central banks may decide to reverse QE to prevent excessive inflation and normalize monetary policy. The process of reversing QE is known as "tapering" or "unwinding."

1. Asset Sales: Central banks can reduce their holdings of financial assets by selling them back into the market.

2. Interest Rate Increases: As the economy strengthens, central banks may raise short-term interest rates to counter inflationary pressures.

3. Gradual Approach: Central banks typically adopt a gradual and cautious approach to unwinding QE to minimize market disruptions and uncertainties.

Conclusion:

Quantitative Easing is a non-conventional monetary policy tool used by central banks to stimulate the economy, increase money supply, and support financial markets during challenging economic conditions. While QE can have positive effects on economic growth and asset prices, it also carries risks, such as asset price bubbles and inflationary pressures. Central banks need to carefully evaluate the impact and risks of QE and implement a well-considered strategy for its eventual reversal.

---

Apart from Quantitative Easing (QE), central banks use various other methods to directly intervene in the banking system to stimulate lending activity and support economic growth. One such method is "Funding for Lending" (FLS). Funding for Lending is a policy tool that provides financial institutions with access to low-cost funding to incentivize them to increase lending to households and businesses.

Funding for Lending (FLS):

1. Low-Cost Funding: The central bank provides funds to commercial banks at low interest rates. These funds are intended to reduce banks' borrowing costs, making it cheaper for them to raise funds and, in turn, offer loans to their customers at lower interest rates.

2. Encouraging Lending: By offering banks cheaper access to funds, FLS aims to incentivize banks to lend more to households and businesses, thereby boosting borrowing and spending in the economy.

3. Targeted Lending: Funding for Lending schemes may be designed with specific lending targets, such as supporting small businesses, first-time homebuyers, or investments in green projects.

4. Periodic Reviews and Adjustments: Central banks may periodically review the effectiveness of FLS and make adjustments to the scheme as needed to ensure that it continues to support lending activity effectively.

Other Methods of Direct Intervention:

1. Forward Guidance: Central banks use forward guidance to communicate their intentions regarding future monetary policy. By providing clarity on the expected path of interest rates, central banks aim to influence borrowing and spending decisions of households and businesses.

2. Targeted Long-Term Refinancing Operations (TLTROs): Central banks conduct TLTROs to provide long-term funding to banks at favorable interest rates, encouraging them to lend to specific sectors of the economy.

3. Negative Interest Rates: In some cases, central banks implement negative interest rates on banks' reserves held at the central bank. This policy is intended to encourage banks to lend out excess reserves rather than hold them.

4. Asset Purchase Programs: Apart from QE, central banks may purchase specific assets, such as corporate bonds or mortgage-backed securities, to improve market liquidity and support lending to specific sectors.

Effectiveness and Considerations:

The effectiveness of these direct intervention methods depends on various factors, including the prevailing economic conditions, the willingness of banks to lend, and the demand for credit from borrowers.

Central banks must carefully assess the potential risks and benefits of these intervention measures. While direct interventions can stimulate lending and boost economic activity, they may also lead to unintended consequences, such as excessive risk-taking or asset price bubbles. Central banks need to strike a balance between supporting the economy and ensuring financial stability.

Overall, these methods of direct intervention provide central banks with additional tools to influence lending activity and support economic growth beyond conventional monetary policy measures like interest rate changes. However, their success relies on the broader economic environment and the responsiveness of financial institutions and borrowers to these measures.